According to the multi-stakeholder international FAIR (Fostering Age Inclusive Research) Trials Initiative, teenagers with cancer must no longer be blocked from entering adult clinical trials.
Teenagers with cancer must no longer be blocked from entering adult clinical trials, according to the multi- stakeholder international FAIR (Fostering Age Inclusive Research) Trials Initiative.
The FAIR Trials Initiative Group includes paediatric and medical oncologists, parents, NGOs, researchers and industry representatives. The Group states that teenagers with cancer are routinely prevented from trying out potentially lifesaving treatments because of a bureaucratic impediment that means under 18s cannot participate in many trials for new cancer drugs.
Members of the Group are united in calling for a change of common practice and announce that it is right and safe to lower the age of access from 18 to 12 years of age (where medically justified) to enable children/adolescents with cancer to have better access to medicines.
This week, the Group launched a new teenage friendly ‘Stamp of Approval’ encouraging all trials to be made accessible for young people with cancer in a safe and appropriate way.
Chris Copland, parent representative and co-chair of the Group, says: “Clinical trials offer hope that one day we may save the thousands of young lives we lose to cancer every year in Europe alone. However, many trials currently exclude patients under eighteen, though this age limit bears little relation to science, safety or compassion.
“We must change this situation as fast as we can. Our FAIR Trials Initiative is a major step in the right direction.”
Dr Nathalie Gaspar, a paediatric oncologist from the Gustave Roussy Cancer Campus in Paris, says: “My main fear is missing an opportunity to cure a young person, or at the very least being able to extend their young lives. It is utterly unbearable to tell a teenager, just because they are under 18, that they cannot participate in a trial, which may offer their last bit of hope.
“The industry is united in recognising that this 18-year age limit is an artificial one and with no clinical evidence behind it. We now have to work hard to ensure that the practice is changed.”
Professor Pamela Kearns, a Medical Professional (University of Birmingham, Cancer Research UK Clinical Trials Unit in the United Kingdom) and SIOP Europe President, says: “There has been significant progress in the treatment of cancer and survival rates in some areas have greatly improved. However, survival rates have in fact plateaued for certain childhood/teenage cancers. This is especially true for those young people whose cancer has already spread at diagnosis and for some brain tumours and sarcomas.
“We understand more about cancer now and much better, kinder drugs are becoming available downstream. We must make sure that our young people have the same access as adults if we are to see improvements in treatments and survival rates. This really is an urgent matter.”
It is surprising to learn how far research into young people’s cancer lags behind that for adults. More than 100 children and young people die of cancer in Europe each week, and cancer is therefore the biggest killer by disease in this age group.
The Group strongly anticipates that age limits will not be a barrier in the future. The prospect to participate in clinical trials shouldn’t be about whether a child is below or above 18 years of age. Instead, it should be about the way the drug works, the biology of the disease and the needs of the patient. The future of clinical trials must change to meet the needs and the future of our young people.
Paediatric oncologists and parents are available for press/broadcast interview to provide further details on this issue. Please contact: Carole.Lecinse@gustaveroussy.fr
• FAIR Trials Initiative call to action video
• FAIR Trials Resources (FAIR Investigations/Sponsor Toolkit; FAIR for AYA ‘Stamp of Approval’; E- learning tools)
• Detailed information catering to various stakeholders (paediatric & medical oncologists; patient & parent advocates; industry and regulators)
‘Fostering Age Inclusive Research’ (FAIR) Trials Initiative Group
Research into teenage and young adults’ cancer has made slower progress than for any other age group. One reason is that many clinical trials exclude patients under 18, without medical justification. To confront this problem, ‘Fostering Age Inclusive Research’ (FAIR) Trials Initiative Group was established in 2017 by the ACCELERATE Forum. Made up of 15 experts from Academia, Industry and Parents/Patients advocacy, the group aims to raise awareness and promote change. You can find out about the group’s work and what you can do to help here.
NOTE TO EDITORS
• In Europe and North America respectively, more than 46 000 and 29 000 adolescents and young people (aged 15 to 24) are diagnosed with cancer every year 1
• In Europe and North America respectively, more than 6 000 and 3 000 adolescents and young people (aged 15 to 24) die of cancer each year 1
• Several cancers in adolescents and young adults have dismal prognosis (metastatic form and some histological types) with few chances of cure and improvement over the years 2
• 80% are disease-free after 5 years from diagnosis, thanks to currently available multidisciplinary treatments and good histology cancer incidence in adolescents and young adults 3
• Two-thirds of survivors experience long-term side effects of treatment, which are severe and impact on the daily life of half of those affected 3
• Beyond 5 years from diagnosis, disease-free survivors of a cancer occurring at adolescence and young adulthood have higher mortality rates than their non-affected peers 4
1. Global Cancer Observatory, Globocan 2018 (http://gco.iarc.fr)
2. Survival of European adolescents and young adults diagnosed with cancer in 2000–07: population-based data from EUROCARE-5. Annalisa Trama, Laura Botta, Roberto Foschi, Andrea Ferrari, Charles Stiller, Emmanuel Desandes, Milena Maria Maule, Franco Merletti, Gemma Gatta, and the EUROCARE-5 Working Group*. DOI:10.1016/S1470-2045(16)00162-5
3. Late Morbidity Leading to Hospitalization Among 5-year Survivors of Young Adult Cancer: A Report of the Childhood, Adolescent and Young Adult Cancer Survivors Research Program. Zhang et al. International Journal of Cancer, 2014
4. Robison, et al. Nature review cancer, 2014
Support: No funding was received in the publication of this Insight article.
Published: 19 February 2020
Journal articles and more to your inbox
Get the latest clinical insights from touchONCOLOGYSign me up!